Obtaining an Intra-Corporate Transfer (ICT) residence permit in Spain is an important step for international companies relocating employees. But securing the initial authorization does not necessarily guarantee a straightforward renewal.
This was the challenge faced by a Japanese professional transferred to Spain from his company’s headquarters in Japan. Although Sterna Abogados had successfully handled his initial ICT residence authorization, the renewal was denied after the Spanish immigration authorities questioned whether his role qualified as a specialist.
Rather than pursuing an appeal, our legal team reassessed the case, developed a more detailed application and worked with the companies in Japan and Spain to address the authorities’ concerns.
The new ICT renewal application was approved.
The case: A Japanese specialist transferred to Spain
The employee had been transferred from his company’s headquarters in Japan to work for its Spanish entity under an Intra-Corporate Transfer residence authorization.
The ICT route allows qualifying international companies to transfer certain employees to Spain for professional assignments. Depending on the circumstances and applicable legal requirements, it can be used for transfers involving managers, specialists and other eligible personnel.
For international businesses, this authorization can be particularly useful when transferring employees with company-specific expertise, technical knowledge or responsibilities that require coordination between different countries.
In this case, Sterna Abogados had successfully managed the employee’s initial residence authorization.
However, when the company sought to renew his permit, an unexpected obstacle arose.
Why was the ICT residence renewal denied in Spain?
The Spanish immigration authorities denied the renewal because they were not satisfied that the employee’s professional position qualified as a specialist role.
Although the employee had already been authorized to work in Spain under the ICT framework, the authorities questioned whether his responsibilities and professional qualifications sufficiently demonstrated the specialized nature of his assignment.
The case also raised concerns about whether his salary was appropriate for the professional position.
This presented a significant challenge for the company and its employee: the initial approval had not eliminated the need to demonstrate continued compliance with the requirements applicable to the renewal.
During the interview for our Moving to Spain: Real Stories series, Ainhoa Manero, immigration lawyer and CEO of Sterna Abogados, explained that ICT renewals had become increasingly demanding in her recent experience.
In particular, she highlighted the importance of demonstrating the employee’s qualifications and specialized knowledge, including how their education, professional background and expertise relate to the position performed in Spain.
For international employers, this means that a previously successful immigration strategy may need to be reassessed before the next renewal.
Sterna Abogados’ legal strategy: A new ICT renewal application
Following the denial, the legal team faced an important strategic decision: challenge the refusal through an appeal or prepare a new application addressing the issues identified by the authorities.
After assessing the circumstances, Sterna chose to submit a new ICT renewal application.
This distinction matters. An appeal challenges an administrative decision, while a new application provides an opportunity to present the case again with revised arguments and supporting documentation, provided the applicant’s circumstances and procedural position allow it.
The new strategy focused on two central issues.
1. Demonstrating the employee’s specialist knowledge
The original renewal had been refused because the authorities were not convinced that the position met the specialist criteria.
Sterna therefore placed greater emphasis on the employee’s role in transferring knowledge from the Japanese headquarters to the Spanish entity.
Rather than relying only on a general description of his responsibilities, the new application explained how the employee’s company-specific expertise was being applied and shared in Spain.
The objective was to establish a clearer connection between his knowledge, the professional assignment and the specialist nature of the transfer.
This approach addressed the central concern raised in the initial denial.
2. Addressing the employee’s salary
The legal team also addressed the salary concerns associated with the employee’s professional position.
Working with the companies involved, Sterna incorporated an explanation of the planned salary increase into the renewed application.
This helped strengthen the presentation of the employee’s professional profile and the conditions associated with his assignment in Spain.
The strategy required coordination between the Japanese headquarters and the Spanish entity, ensuring that the immigration arguments reflected the employee’s actual responsibilities and the company’s plans.
The result was a more comprehensive application addressing the specific issues that had led to the original refusal.
The outcome: ICT residence renewal successfully approved
Following the revised legal strategy and submission of the new application, the Spanish immigration authorities approved the employee’s ICT residence renewal.
The successful outcome demonstrates the importance of understanding the reasons behind an immigration refusal before deciding how to proceed.
In this case, the legal team did not simply repeat the original application. It identified the authorities’ concerns, developed additional justification of the employee’s specialist role and addressed the salary issue through coordination with the employer.
The case also illustrates why an immigration denial does not necessarily mean that an employee’s assignment in Spain cannot continue.
Depending on the circumstances, a new application may offer an appropriate route to resolving the problem.
What international companies can learn from this ICT renewal case
The experience of this Japanese specialist highlights several considerations for international employers managing ICT permits in Spain.
Review specialist eligibility carefully. Companies should ensure that the employee’s qualifications, knowledge and responsibilities are consistent with the immigration category under which the transfer is requested.
Prepare for renewals from the beginning. An initial authorization should form part of a longer-term immigration plan. Employers need to consider how the employee’s position, documentation and circumstances may evolve.
Evaluate alternatives before appealing a refusal. Depending on the reasons for denial, the employee’s legal position and applicable deadlines, a new application may be worth considering instead of an administrative appeal.
Plan beyond the next renewal. International assignments can change over time. Companies should assess whether renewing an ICT authorization, modifying the employee’s immigration status or pursuing another available route is the most appropriate long-term strategy.
These considerations are particularly relevant for HR and Global Mobility teams responsible for maintaining immigration compliance across international workforces.
Corporate immigration support in Spain with Sterna Abogados
International employee transfers require more than obtaining an initial residence permit. They also involve ongoing planning, compliance assessments and coordination between employers in different jurisdictions.
At Sterna Abogados, we advise international companies on Intra-Corporate Transfer (ICT) authorizations, residence renewals, immigration refusals and other corporate mobility procedures in Spain.
Our approach combines individualized legal analysis with practical coordination between companies, employees and the relevant immigration authorities.
If your company is preparing an international employee transfer, facing difficulties with an ICT renewal or evaluating its immigration strategy in Spain, contact our team to discuss your circumstances.
Contact our team at Sterna Abogados for specialized corporate immigration assistance in Spain.